Pettalk

Discussions »Laws

69799

AB 1634 is DEAD in California

Connie on Laws - Fri, August 22 2008

For the last year, the California state legislature has been looking at legislation that would require mandatory spay and neuter for cats and dogs. This bill was touted by the HSUS as a "model" bill which they hoped to then get other states/cities to pass. Chicago is even now considering mandatory s/n.
Today AB 1634 was declared dead in legislation. Phew.

While I believe dogs and cats SHOULD be spayed and neutered I do not believe legislation is the answer. It only hurts those who are already law abiding and it causes people who don't want to abide by the law to go under ground and perhaps not take their pets to the vet at all.

One of the things I really like about Nathan Winograd and his no kill equation is that he preaches no kill can be done without legislation. It always seems that one animal law leads to another and the next thing you know breed specific legislation rears its ugly head.

If you want to read more about this bill you can visit http://www.petpac.net/

Pet Pac did a lot of impact studies, which I'm now hoping the Chicago city council look at. One of the reasons Chicago put forward for mandatory s/n was all the unaltered pit bulls owned by gang members. As one Chicago columnist put it: if the gang members don't mind carrying unlicensed guns, why in the world would they suddenly decide to abide by a law requiring their dog be altered!

dreya on Aug 22 at 05:28 PM

76448

I'm sure all the hoods in "Chi town" ran right down to the nearest s/n clinic. Yeah, right.

I totally agree with what you said about how it "only hurts those who are already law abiding." Thanks for posting this.

Diane on Aug 22 at 08:44 PM

108110

Thanks for the post. Agree that legislation is not the answer, when it certainly hasn't made a difference so far, pet responsibility is a moral obligation and it shouldn't have to be enforced. xoxo D

Amanda on Aug 22 at 09:08 PM

87757

I was thinking about this the other day and really how do you enforce a spaid female? There may be a spay scar but it's not always easy to find..... Just pondering

Connie on Aug 23 at 06:55 AM

69799
Amanda said:
I was thinking about this the other day and really how do you enforce a spaid female? There may be a spay scar but it's not always easy to find..... Just pondering

That's also one of the problems opposition groups mention. Enforcement will probably be more expensive than the problem of unaltered dogs. Who wants their dog to have surgery just to find out it was already spayed in the past?

One of my relatives is a judge and said he just can't even imagine what kind of enforcement issues something like this would bring about.

Stacy on Aug 23 at 07:36 AM

77200

I think we have too many laws as it is. What we don't have enough of is low-cost spay/neuter clinics. If they took the money they were going to waste trying to enforce this law and opened a low-cost clinic, they would see people spaying/neutering their pets. There are some people who act like making a law solves the problem. Making a law really doesn't do anything. The key to change is education and changing people's attitudes. Along with that, you have to make things affordable and available to everyone.

Freda on Aug 23 at 09:01 AM

93147
Stacy said:
I think we have too many laws as it is. What we don't have enough of is low-cost spay/neuter clinics. If they took the money they were going to waste trying to enforce this law and opened a low-cost clinic, they would see people spaying/neutering their pets. There are some people who act like making a law solves the problem. Making a law really doesn't do anything. The key to change is education and changing people's attitudes. Along with that, you have to make things affordable and available to everyone.

Affirmative on that Stacy!

Search Classifieds:
GoGo
Call 317.444.4444 to place an ad
What you need to keep your pet happy and healthy.
Indiana_paw_logo
IndyPaws.com is proud to be partnered with Indiana Proactive Animal Welfare to bring you a wealth of pet care, health, and adoption information.
Visit Indiana Proactive Animal Welfare

Use of this site signifies your agreement to the Terms of Service and Privacy Policy/Your California Privacy Rights, updated August, 2006.
Copyright © 2007 The Indianapolis Star Media Group. All rights reserved.